US News

More than a third of working families can’t afford basic needs: study

More than a third of US families that work full-time do not earn enough money to cover their most basic needs, including housing, food and child care, a new study shows.

Researchers at Brandeis University found 35% of American families do not meet the “basic family needs budget” — the amount needed to afford rent, food, transportation, medical care and minimal household expenses — despite working full-time year-round.

And the economic situation is even more dire for working black and Hispanic families, more than 50% of whom cannot afford the basics.

For comparison, a quarter of white families and 23% of Asian and Pacific Islander families are struggling to make rent and buy food, despite holding down full-time jobs.

A study by researchers at Brandeis University’s diversitydatakids.org program shows that 35% of American families with full-time jobs cannot afford the basics. The Russell Sage Foundation
Jesus Montiel, Krista Mason and their daughter, Diana, 2, spend time together at their home in Wyoming, where inflation has been hitting families hard. The Washington Post via Getty Im

Low-income families with children are doing especially poorly, according to the survey, with more than two-thirds of full-time workers failing to earn enough to make ends meet.

Most of these families would need to earn about $11 more per hour to fully cover basic expenses, or about $23,500 in additional annual earnings, according to the research.

Meanwhile, black and Hispanic families would need to earn more than $12 per hour — an additional $26,500 per year — just to meet a family budget.

“These results are a wake-up call for decision makers to prioritize policies that address income inequality and racial and ethnic equity and extend real opportunities for economic self-sufficiency,” said Dr. Pamela Joshi, senior research scientist and lead study author.

People wait in line to receive packages of food during an Alameda County Community Food Bank food giveaway at Acts Full Gospel Church on July 15, 2022, in Oakland, California. Getty Images
Most of these families would need to earn about $11 more per hour to fully cover basic expenses. The Russell Sage Foundation

The study, which is based on 98,000 households, also found that more than half of low-income Hispanic families do not have health insurance, and more than three-quarters do not have pensions.

“When families can’t afford their basic needs, it places stress on parents’ health, and it increases the likelihood that children will continue to lack resources and opportunities that promote their well-being,” said study co-author Dr. Dolores Acevedo-Garcia.

The study offers several recommendations to policymakers to improve the economic outlook for low-income families, including creating more jobs that provide a living wage, expanding income support, and paid family and medical leave.

The results of the survey are based on data from 2015 to 2019, before the outbreak of the coronavirus pandemic that wreaked havoc on the job market, and before the recent spikes in inflation, gasoline and food prices.

In a more recent Gallup web survey conducted last month amid surging inflation, more than half of respondents — 56% — said they are facing financial hardships due to price increases. 

Of those who reported facing financial hardship, 12% described the hardship as severe, while 44% said it was moderate, according to the poll which was published on Wednesday.

People gather for a rent relief rally at Gov. Kathy Hochul’s NYC office on May 6, 2022, in New York City. Getty Images

The poll found that lower-income Americans are more likely to experience severe hardship, with 26% of those with an annual household income of less than $48,000 reporting that rising costs are causing severe hardship for their families, compared to just 12% of middle-income Americans and 4% of upper-income Americans.

However, the poll also found that middle-income Amerians and upper-income families experienced a stark increase among those who reported experiencing financial hardships from last fall — up 17% and 12%, respectively.

Those experiencing hardship have been forced to make significant sacrifices in their lives, the poll found.  The most popular action taken, which 24% of respondents reported, was to buy only essential items.

An additional 17% said they are traveling less and canceling vacations to save funds. Another 17% said they were driving less to save money on gas, which ballooned to over $5 a gallon nationally in June. 

Others have been forced to take more dramatic measures including delaying medical appointments and procedures (3%) and selling what they can or downsizing (2%).